Consumption Taxes & Tax Rates Drive the Poor Into Poverty
How Consumption Taxes Are So Unfair To the Poor
Ever feel like you just can’t catch a break? Like the system is rigged against you? If you’re struggling to make ends meet, the US tax code likely isn’t doing you any favors. While the wealthy and big corporations enjoy loopholes and tax breaks, you’re stuck paying up to fund the government. And when you can barely afford rent or groceries as it is, those taxes feel like an unfair burden pushing you ever closer to the poverty line.
The Increasing Tax Burden on the Poor and Social Policy
The tax burden on lower-income Americans has been growing over time. While the wealthy and big corporations enjoy generous tax breaks and loopholes, the poor face a higher percentage of their income going to taxes.
For starters, sales taxes on goods and services take a much bigger bite out of the poor’s earnings. If you’re living paycheck to paycheck, an extra few cents on the dollar for every purchase really adds up. Not to mention so-called “sin taxes” on things like cigarettes and alcohol, which the poor tend to consume more of.
At the same time, the poor receive fewer tax benefits. They usually can’t take advantage of deductions for mortgages, retirement funds, or college savings since they struggle just to pay for basic necessities. Many tax credits and rebates also favor the middle class.
To make matters worse, low-income households typically pay higher tax rates than the wealthy. While the affluent earn most of their income from investments taxed at lower rates, the poor rely entirely on wages and salaries taxed at higher rates. It’s a system that perpetuates the cycle of poverty.
There’s no question the poor face an unfair tax burden in the U.S. While everyone should pay their fair share, a system with more equitable rates, broader tax benefits, and fewer loopholes for the rich could help lift more Americans out of poverty. Tax reform may be complicated, but it’s sorely needed to establish a just society with equal opportunity for all.
How the US Tax Code Disproportionately Impacts Low-Income Households
The US tax code is complicated, to say the least. For low-income households, it can feel downright unfair. While the wealthy and big corporations enjoy loopholes and tax breaks, the little guy ends up shouldering a disproportionate amount of the tax burden because of consumption taxes.
For starters, the US has a regressive tax system, meaning low-income individuals pay a higher percentage of their income in taxes than the rich. Sales taxes, for example, take a much bigger bite out of the budget of someone earning $30,000 a year versus $300,000. The earned income tax credit was meant to offset this imbalance but fails to fully compensate.
Current Tax Code Keeps Many Taxpayers Below Federal Poverty Level
The tax code is also riddled with deductions and credits that largely benefit high-income households and big business. Things like mortgage interest deductions and tax breaks for oil companies and private jets predominantly help the affluent. The average person earning $50,000 a year sees little benefit.
At the same time, low-income families face higher tax rates for essentials like food, housing, and transportation. In some states, families earning less than $25,000 annually pay up to 7% of their income in sales and excise taxes on basic necessities. Wealthier households, on the other hand, spend a much lower percentage of their income on these essentials and thus pay a lower effective tax rate.
It’s clear the US tax system disproportionately impacts the poor. Reforming the tax code to eliminate loopholes, increase credits for low-income groups, and make the overall system more progressive could help remedy this imbalance and support those who need it most. The affluent have had tax breaks for too long. Isn’t it time we gave the little guy a break?
Tax Loopholes and Breaks Benefiting the Wealthy
While lower and middle-income individuals face a higher tax burden relative to their income, the wealthy and large corporations frequently take advantage of loopholes and tax breaks to lower their tax bills.
Offshore Tax Havens
Many wealthy individuals and corporations shelter their money in offshore tax havens to avoid paying U.S. taxes. They move their money to countries with little or no tax on certain types of income like capital gains or business profits. This allows them to avoid paying billions in taxes each year.
The wealthy can take advantage of charitable tax deductions that are disproportionately beneficial to them. While the intention of charitable deductions is good, the system favors the affluent who can afford to donate property, art, or stocks rather than just cash. The tax benefits they receive often far outweigh the actual value of the donation.
Some of the largest and most profitable corporations pay little to no federal income taxes due to various loopholes and subsidies. Billions of dollars are spent each year on corporate welfare programs like farm subsidies, oil subsidies, and economic development grants. While small businesses struggle, huge corporations with record profits are essentially receiving government handouts.
Carried Interest Loophole
Hedge fund managers and private equity executives can classify a large portion of their income as “carried interest” which is taxed at a lower capital gains rate rather than the higher income tax rate. This loophole allows some of the wealthiest people in the country to pay a lower tax rate than average working Americans. There have been many attempts to close this loophole, but powerful lobbying groups have prevented much progress.
The tax code is filled with loopholes and breaks that overwhelmingly benefit the affluent and large corporations. While the middle class faces a higher relative tax burden, the wealthiest members of society are able to exploit the system to lower or eliminate their tax bills. Comprehensive tax reform is needed to make the system fairer and more equitable for all.
Do Corporate Tax Breaks Really Create Jobs?
The Myth of Trickle-Down Economics
Proponents of corporate tax cuts argue that reducing the tax burden on big businesses will spur economic growth and job creation. The idea is that companies will use the extra money from tax savings to invest in their businesses, buy new equipment, open new locations, and hire more workers. This is the theory of “trickle-down economics”—tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations will trickle down to the rest of the economy.
However, numerous studies have found little evidence to support this theory. Corporations may use tax windfalls to boost executive pay, reward shareholders through dividends and stock buybacks, or make acquisitions. While these moves benefit higher-ups and investors, they do little for job creation.
According to Americans for Tax Fairness, the corporate tax cuts in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act resulted in companies spending over $1 trillion on stock buybacks and dividends, but only 6% of that amount on bonuses and wage increases for workers.
- Tax cuts often do not translate to higher wages or more jobs. Companies maximize profits, not employment.
- Extra cash is frequently distributed to executives and shareholders, not rank-and-file workers.
- Corporations may use tax savings for things like automation that actually reduce jobs.
- Tax cuts deprive the government of revenue needed for programs that help low-income individuals, families and communities.
While corporate tax reform may be needed to simplify the tax code and encourage business investment, simply cutting rates is not an effective or equitable solution. There are better ways to boost economic growth, such as investing in infrastructure, education, job training programs, and small businesses. Trickle-down economics is a myth that disproportionately benefits the wealthy while failing to generate substantial gains for most Americans. The burden of taxation must be distributed fairly if we want an economy that works for everyone.
Reforming the Tax Code to Relieve the Tax Burden on the Poor
The current U.S. tax code places an unfair burden on the poor. Reforming it to relieve this burden could help lift many out of poverty.
Simplify the Tax Code
The tax code is overly complex, with too many loopholes and deductions that primarily benefit the wealthy. Simplifying the code by eliminating many deductions and lowering tax rates could make the system fairer. The poor often can’t take advantage of deductions and credits due to their complexity. Lower, flatter tax rates would reduce the tax burden on low-income households.
Expand Tax Credits for the Poor
Programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Child Tax Credit (CTC) help offset the cost of raising children for low-income families. Expanding these credits could provide much-needed financial relief. Raising income thresholds for the credits would allow more households to benefit. Increasing the amount of the CTC in particular would help address the high cost of childcare and other child-rearing expenses.
Tax Corporations and the Wealthy Fairly
While the poor pay a higher percentage of their income in taxes, large corporations and the wealthy often pay very little in taxes due to loopholes and tax avoidance. Closing loopholes, limiting deductions, and increasing tax rates on capital gains and corporate income could generate hundreds of billions in revenue. This revenue could fund programs that help lift Americans out of poverty like healthcare, education, job training programs, and more.
Reforming the tax code will require political will, but it can be done in a way that eases the burden on the poor, promotes fairness, and funds programs vital to economic mobility. Simplifying the code, expanding tax credits for the poor, and ensuring corporations and the wealthy pay their fair share would be steps in the right direction. The poor deserve a tax system that helps improve their lives, not one that pushes them further and further below the federal poverty level.
So there you have it. While taxes are necessary to fund important government services we all benefit from, it seems the system has become unfairly skewed against the little guy. If you’re struggling just to put food on the table, an extra couple hundred bucks a year in taxes can really hurt. At the same time, the wealthy and big companies have armies of accountants to find them loopholes and shelters to avoid paying their fair share.
Something has to change. Our tax code needs an overhaul to make it simpler and fairer. No one should be taxed into poverty while others get a free ride. Call your political representatives and tell them you want tax reform that benefits hardworking families. Together, we can make a difference. Unfortunately, however, consumption taxes will continue to be a problem for the poor for the foreseeable future.
- How to Save Tax: The Ultimate Guide for Smart Savings - September 20, 2023
- Flat Tax vs. Income Tax: Pros and Cons - September 13, 2023
- The Basics of Financial Literacy for Beginners - September 6, 2023